Explainer

Fake Amazon Reviews: How They Are Made, Bought and Hidden in 2026

By Andrew KaneUpdated 9 min read
Laptop showing sales charts next to shipping boxes

Reviews move sales on Amazon, so some sellers buy them. The economics are simple: a better rating improves search placement, which brings more buyers, which brings more genuine reviews that bury the fake ones. Researchers studying the market found that rating manipulation had a large causal effect on sales (He, Hollenbeck and Proserpio).

Who Sells Fake Reviews?

Most fake reviews come from review brokers. The academic study above followed about 1,500 products that solicited fake reviews over nine months through large private groups on Facebook and other sites (paper). Typically, the shopper buys the product, posts a 5-star review and is refunded afterward.

Amazon has filed a long series of lawsuits against these operations since 2015. It names cases against broker sites including ReviewServiceUSA.com (filed with the Better Business Bureau in July 2024), AMZ Mastery (May 2024) and Bigboostup.com (in parallel with a suit by Google), and says thousands of bad actors faced enforcement in 2024 (Amazon).

The Six Main Types of Fake Amazon Reviews

1. Refund-for-Review (Incentivized) Reviews

A real person buys the product and gets their money back for a positive review. Because the purchase is real, the review can carry the Verified Purchase badge, which makes these reviews hard to spot one at a time.

Because the shopper really buys the product, these reviews carry the badge; here's what Verified Purchase does and doesn't mean. Amazon's own Vine program is different: its free-product reviews are labeled and come through Amazon, not the seller.

2. AI-Written Reviews

Large language models write fluent, specific-sounding reviews in seconds. One detection vendor estimated that the share of Amazon reviews with substantial AI content rose about 400% after ChatGPT launched in late 2022 (Originality.ai, 2025). Another found about 3% of front-page reviews on Amazon bestsellers were AI-generated with high confidence (Pangram Labs, 2026).

3. Brushing

A seller ships an item to someone who never ordered it, then uses that "delivery" to post a fake review in the recipient's name. The FTC warns that an unexpected package can also signal that someone has your personal information (FTC, 2026).

If a package you didn't order turns up, here's what to do about a brushing scam.

4. Review Hijacking and Variation Merging

A new product is attached to an older listing, or an old listing is rewritten as a different product, so it inherits the reviews. The FTC's first case on the practice ended with The Bountiful Company paying $600,000 (FTC). See how to check a listing for review hijacking.

5. Insider and Family Reviews

Employees, owners or relatives post reviews without disclosing the connection. The FTC's rule bans undisclosed insider reviews and bans companies from asking employees to solicit reviews from their families.

6. Fake Negative Reviews and Review Suppression

Some sellers buy 1-star reviews of competitors. Others suppress bad reviews of their own products, for example with threats or by only asking happy customers to review. Both are prohibited under the FTC rule (Alston & Bird summary).

Why Fake Reviews Stay Up for Months

Detection is slow. In the Marketing Science study, roughly half of the reviews on products that bought fake reviews were eventually deleted, but the average lag was more than 100 days. By then the campaign has already done its job: higher rank, more sales, more genuine reviews.

What Amazon and Regulators Are Doing

WhoActionSource
AmazonBlocked 250M+ suspected fake reviews in 2023 and 275M+ in 2024; "hundreds of millions" in 2025Amazon, Amazon
US FTCRule banning fake and AI-generated reviews, in effect October 21, 2024; penalties up to $53,088 per violation (the 2025 amount, kept for 2026)Alston & Bird, FTC
UK CMADMCC Act bans fake and concealed incentivized reviews from April 6, 2025; fines up to 10% of global turnoverCMS

What This Means for Shoppers

You can't rely on the star rating or the Verified Purchase badge alone. The patterns these tactics leave behind are visible, though: review bursts, ratings that slide after a campaign ends, reviews that describe a different product, and generic praise. The step-by-step guide on how to spot fake Amazon reviews covers each one, and FakeFind's free checker looks for review bursts, ratings that slide and reviews about a different product on listings from ten Amazon stores, in under a minute.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do sellers get fake Amazon reviews?

Many buy them through brokers who recruit shoppers in private online groups. Typically, the shopper buys the product, posts a 5-star review and is refunded afterward. Other methods include AI-written reviews, brushing, undisclosed insider reviews and attaching a new product to an older listing's reviews.

Are fake Amazon reviews illegal?

In the US, the FTC rule that took effect on October 21, 2024 bans creating, buying or selling fake reviews, including AI-generated ones, with civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation (the 2025 amount, which the FTC kept for 2026). The UK banned fake reviews under the DMCC Act from April 6, 2025. Amazon's own policies also prohibit them.

How many fake reviews does Amazon remove?

Amazon says it blocked more than 250 million suspected fake reviews in 2023, more than 275 million in 2024 and hundreds of millions in 2025.

Can fake reviews have the Verified Purchase badge?

Yes. Refund-for-review schemes and brushing both involve real orders, so the reviews they produce can carry the Verified Purchase badge.

Sources

  1. Study examines the impact of fake online reviews on sales ("The Market for Fake Reviews", Marketing Science) — INFORMS — He, Hollenbeck and Proserpio, September 9, 2022
  2. The Market for Fake Reviews (working paper) — SSRN
  3. Amazon's latest actions against fake review brokers — Amazon
  4. Trustworthy reviews — Amazon Trustworthy Shopping
  5. AI Content in Amazon Reviews — Originality.ai (AI-detection vendor), November 17, 2025
  6. Three percent of front-page Amazon reviews are now AI-generated — Pangram Labs (AI-detection vendor), May 4, 2026
  7. That unexpected package you got could be a brushing scam — FTC Consumer Advice, August 20, 2026
  8. The Bountiful Company (case 222-3019) — Federal Trade Commission
  9. FTC issues final rule on fake reviews and testimonials — Alston & Bird, October 22, 2024
  10. FTC publishes inflation-adjusted civil penalty amounts for 2025 — Federal Trade Commission, February 2025
  11. No more faux five-stars: the DMCC Act bans fake reviews — CMS

Check an Amazon Product Now

Paste any Amazon link to see how much you can trust its reviews. Free, no account.